| Game | Home Player | Away Player | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Paul Taylor | 0 - 1 | Stephen MacDonald |
| 2 | Kieran Underwood | 1 - 0 | Ray Myers |
| 3 | Ed Merola | 0 - 1 | Adam Armstrong |
| 4 | Ryan Froggatt | 0 - 1 | Adam Dowson |
| 5 | Mat Bate | 0 - 1 | Terry Cooper |
| 6 | Michael O'Rourke | 0 - 1 | John Brown |
| 7 | Paul Taylor | 0 - 1 | Adam Armstrong |
| 8 | Kieran Underwood | 1 - 0 | Adam Dowson |
| 9 | Ed Merola | 1 - 0 | Terry Cooper |
| 10 | Ryan Froggatt | 1 - 0 | John Brown |
| 11 | Mat Bate | 0 - 1 | Stephen MacDonald |
| 12 | Michael O'Rourke | 1 - 0 | Ray Myers |
| 5 - 7 |